McGill’s electric bus grant rejection has developed into a legal dispute over the Scottish Government’s £45 million ScotZEB3 funding round.
McGill’s sought approximately £4.36 million towards 33 Alexander Dennis battery-electric buses and 13 chargers, but its application was unsuccessful when five other applicants received funding.
The dispute has since moved to the Competition Appeal Tribunal. McGill’s argues that there were legal problems with how ScotZEB3 was established and treated under the Subsidy Control Act 2022. Those claims have not been upheld by the Tribunal at this stage.
As of September 2026, the case remains ongoing. A one-day case management conference is scheduled in Edinburgh for 26 October 2026, where the Tribunal is expected to consider, among other issues, whether McGill’s appeal was filed within the required time.
How Did McGill’s Electric Bus Grant Dispute Start?
The dispute began after McGill’s submitted an application to the third phase of the Scottish Zero Emission Bus Challenge Fund, known as ScotZEB3.
ScotZEB3 was announced in November 2025 with up to £45 million available.
Applications opened on 5 December 2025 and closed on 26 February 2026. The programme was intended to accelerate the introduction of zero-emission vehicles and supporting charging infrastructure.
On 25 March 2026, the Scottish Government announced the successful applicants. McGill’s was not among them.
The operator had requested about £4.3 million in government support for a project involving 33 zero-emission buses from Alexander Dennis.
McGill’s said the wider procurement would have been worth approximately £16 million and argued that it would have supported Scottish manufacturing employment.
McGill’s initially announced that it would seek legal advice over the decision. The dispute later escalated into a formal Competition Appeal Tribunal case.
Timeline Of The McGill’s ScotZEB3 Funding Dispute
| Date | Development |
| August 2025 | A further £40 million of zero-emission bus funding was proposed through the earlier ScotZEB2 arrangements |
| November 2025 | Transport Scotland announced ScotZEB3 as the third and final phase |
| 5 December 2025 | ScotZEB3 opened for applications |
| 26 February 2026 | Applications closed |
| 9 March 2026 | ScotZEB3 moderation panel considered applications |
| 25 March 2026 | Five successful applicants were announced and McGill’s did not receive funding |
| 17 April 2026 | McGill’s made a request for information under the Subsidy Control Act |
| 15 May 2026 | Scottish Ministers responded to the information request |
| 10 June 2026 | Competition Appeal Tribunal received McGill’s appeal |
| 9 July 2026 | Tribunal published its Summary of Appeal |
| 3 August 2026 | Tribunal issued an order setting arrangements for the case management conference |
| 26 October 2026 | One-day case management conference scheduled in Edinburgh |
The timeline shows that the case has moved beyond a disagreement over the outcome of a grant application. It now concerns the legal status of the ScotZEB3 scheme and whether the appeal itself was submitted within the applicable time limit.
What Happened To McGill’s ScotZEB3 Funding Application?
McGill’s sought £4.36 million towards 33 Alexander Dennis battery-electric buses and 13 chargers. The proposed Scottish Government contribution was therefore only one part of the wider investment.
The company said the vehicle order would have represented around £16 million of business for Alexander Dennis, whose Larbert operations formed part of the Scottish manufacturing argument made by McGill’s.

The £16 million figure should not be confused with the amount of public money requested.
McGill’s was seeking about £4.3 million from ScotZEB3, while the larger figure referred to the value associated with the proposed vehicle investment.
McGill’s application was eligible to be considered, but it ultimately received no ScotZEB3 grant.
How Did ScotZEB3 Develop From The Earlier ScotZEB Funding Scheme?
ScotZEB3 followed two earlier stages of Scotland’s zero-emission bus funding programme.
Under ScotZEB1, McGill’s itself received support. Transport Scotland records an offered award of approximately £9.09 million for 41 buses, with about £8.66 million eventually claimed.
ScotZEB2 worked differently. It focused on consortium applications, with a £41.7 million award made to a Zenobē-led consortium. McGill’s was among the businesses involved.
A further £40 million was later expected to be made available through ScotZEB2.
That approach changed and the funding was instead moved towards a new competitive ScotZEB3 process. ScotZEB3 eventually provided up to £45 million and did not require applicants to apply through consortia.
This change has become important to the legal dispute because McGill’s challenges how ScotZEB3 was characterised for subsidy-control purposes.
How Were ScotZEB3 Applications Assessed And Scored?
Official assessment documents show that applications were judged across four main areas.
| Assessment Criterion | Weighting |
| Financial | 40% |
| Deliverability | 30% |
| Market Development, Business And Economy | 20% |
| Wider Community And Decarbonisation Benefits | 10% |
Each criterion was scored from zero to three.
A score of 0 represented an unacceptable application in that criterion, while 1 was weak, 2 was acceptable and 3 was strong.
The financial assessment carried the largest weighting. Within that 40%, 30 percentage points related to subsidy ranking and 10 percentage points related to the viability of the financial evidence.
Applications also needed an unweighted score of at least 2 in both Financial and Deliverability to remain under consideration for an award.
Applications failing those minimum thresholds did not progress to the later comparative stage.
Why Did McGill’s Not Receive ScotZEB3 Funding?
There is an important distinction between what is publicly established and what remains unclear.
Official records confirm that McGill’s application was unsuccessful. They also explain the overall scoring framework and confirm that minimum thresholds applied.
However, publicly released information does not provide a complete unredacted account that allows readers to reconstruct every score given to McGill’s and identify a single definitive reason for rejection.
The Scottish Government has said that applications were assessed in stages.
Those meeting minimum Financial and Deliverability requirements progressed to comparative assessment, including subsidy ranking, with available funding then directed towards the highest-scoring qualifying proposals.
Some internal guidance, scoring sheets and commercially sensitive material have been withheld or redacted.
Therefore, it would be inaccurate to state a specific individual scoring failure for McGill’s unless further official information establishes it.
Who Received The £45 Million ScotZEB3 Funding Instead?
Five applicants received offers through the £45 million ScotZEB3 programme.
| Applicant | Public Funding | Vehicles |
| Ember | £13,174,147 | 100 |
| Rock Road | £11,500,317.08 | 93 |
| Lothian | £9,567,260 | 60 |
| First Bus | £5,989,966 | 37 |
| Stagecoach | £4,568,280.40 | 44 |
Together, the projects support 334 zero-emission vehicles, including 227 buses and 107 coaches, along with charging infrastructure.
McGill’s has criticised aspects of the allocation, particularly support for new electric coach capacity rather than using all available funding to replace existing diesel buses.
Transport Scotland’s stated objectives are broader.
The programme is also intended to support connectivity, shared infrastructure, rural and island communities, emissions reductions and the development of green supply chains.
Why Has McGill’s Taken The Scottish Ministers To The Competition Appeal Tribunal?
McGill’s appeal is based on the Subsidy Control Act 2022 rather than simply dissatisfaction with losing the funding competition.
The operator argues that ScotZEB3 should not have been treated as a permitted modification of the existing ScotZEB subsidy scheme.
Its principal allegations include:
- Treating ScotZEB3 As A Permitted Modification When McGill’s Argues It Should Not Qualify As One
- Failing To Treat ScotZEB3 As A New Subsidy Scheme
- Failing To Apply Relevant Subsidy Control And Environmental Principles
- Failing To Request Competition And Markets Authority Scrutiny That McGill’s Argues Was Required
- Failing To Make An Appropriate ScotZEB3 Entry On The Subsidy Database
The Scottish Ministers’ position recorded in the appeal summary is that no separate or additional subsidy-control assessment was required for subsequent phases and that ScotZEB3 operated within the scope of the overarching ScotZEB assessment.
These remain competing legal positions. The Tribunal has not yet ruled that the Scottish Ministers committed the alleged errors.
Could McGill’s Appeal Be Affected By The Filing Deadline?
Yes, the timing of the appeal has become an important preliminary issue, although the Tribunal has not yet decided that McGill’s filed late.
The Tribunal’s August order states that the 26 October case management conference will consider whether the Notice of Appeal was filed timeously for the purposes of Section 71 of the Subsidy Control Act 2022 and the Competition Appeal Tribunal Rules.
The parties have been instructed to prepare arguments on that question.
The order also refers to proposed directions for the future conduct of the proceedings if the Employment Tribunal determines that the appeal was filed in time and does not strike it out.
This means the procedural timing question could be addressed before the Tribunal moves fully into McGill’s wider legal arguments about ScotZEB3.
What Will Happen At The 26 October 2026 Tribunal Hearing?
A one-day case management conference is scheduled to take place in person in Edinburgh on 26 October 2026.
The hearing is expected to consider the timeliness of McGill’s appeal along with procedural arrangements for how the case should continue.
Before the conference, both sides are required to exchange relevant documents and prepare legal arguments dealing with the timing issue.
The hearing should not automatically be described as the final determination of whether ScotZEB3 was lawful. Its immediate significance lies in resolving or managing preliminary matters that could influence whether the wider challenge proceeds.
What Has Been Revealed About The ScotZEB3 Assessment Process?
Official information releases have provided much more detail about how ScotZEB3 applications were handled.
The Scottish Government confirmed:
- Nine Applications Were Received
- All Nine Applications Met The Eligibility Criteria
- Four Applicants Received The Full Grant Requested
- One Applicant Received Less Than The Full Amount Requested
- Four Eligible Applicants Received No Grant
Assessment involved representatives from organisations including Horse Transport Scotland, Energy Saving Trust, Scottish Futures Trust and Zemo.
Some information has not been released.
The Scottish Government has cited exemptions covering internal communications, commercial confidentiality, third-party interests and personal data when withholding parts of evaluation documents and scoring information.
What Did McGill’s Rejected Proposal Mean For Alexander Dennis And Scottish Jobs?
McGill’s linked its funding application directly to Scottish manufacturing.
The company intended to purchase 33 zero-emission buses from Alexander Dennis.
It said the overall procurement would have been worth approximately £16 million and would have supported manufacturing activity connected with the company’s Larbert operations.

McGill’s also argued that the proposed buses would replace diesel vehicles within its operations, including fleets associated with Xplore Dundee and Midland Bluebird.
However, the rejection of the grant does not by itself prove that those buses can never be purchased. It means McGill’s did not receive the requested ScotZEB3 support for the project as proposed.
Whether the operator eventually pursues the investment through another financing structure will depend on its commercial decisions and the outcome of the continuing dispute.
How Could The ScotZEB3 Grant Rejection Impact McGill’s Business?
The clearest immediate impact is the loss of approximately £4.36 million of expected public support for the proposed electric fleet expansion.
Potential business implications include:
- Fleet Investment: McGill’s may have to reconsider the timing, financing or scale of the planned 33-bus purchase if it intends to proceed without the grant
- Capital Requirements: Funding the same investment privately could require greater capital from the operator or alternative finance
- Fleet Decarbonisation: The pace at which additional diesel vehicles are replaced could be affected
- Charging Infrastructure: The planned 13 chargers were also part of the unsuccessful proposal
- Legal Costs: Continuing Tribunal proceedings bring additional professional and legal expenditure
- Strategic Planning: Uncertainty over the case could complicate decisions about future zero-emission fleet investment
These should be treated as possible commercial effects rather than confirmed outcomes. McGill’s future fleet strategy will depend on decisions taken by the company and on how the legal proceedings develop.
Why Does The ScotZEB3 Dispute Matter Beyond McGill’s?
The dispute could have significance beyond one bus operator because it raises questions about how public subsidy programmes are structured and modified.
If the Tribunal eventually reaches the substantive legal issues, businesses and public authorities may look closely at what it says about modifying existing subsidy schemes, carrying out new subsidy-control assessments, transparency obligations and the circumstances in which CMA scrutiny is required.
The case could also be relevant to businesses competing for environmental and infrastructure grants because funding programmes increasingly combine public money with substantial private investment.
However, the wider implications will depend on what the Tribunal actually decides. The existence of McGill’s challenge alone does not establish that the ScotZEB3 process was unlawful.
What Happens Next in McGill’s ScotZEB3 Case?
The next confirmed stage is the 26 October 2026 case management conference in Edinburgh.
Attention is likely to focus first on the procedural question surrounding the timing of the appeal.
The main developments to watch are:
- Tribunal Decision On Whether The Appeal Was Filed In Time
- Further Case Management Directions
- Any Decision On Whether The Appeal Proceeds To Substantive Consideration
- Further Evidence Or Arguments From McGill’s And The Scottish Ministers
- Any Subsequent Hearing On The ScotZEB3 Legal Issues
- A Final Judgment Or Other Tribunal Order
Until the Tribunal makes further decisions, McGill’s allegations about the legality of ScotZEB3 remain unresolved.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Much ScotZEB3 Funding Did McGill’s Apply For?
McGill’s sought approximately £4.36 million in ScotZEB3 support. The funding was intended to contribute towards 33 Alexander Dennis battery-electric buses and 13 chargers.
How Many Electric Buses Did McGill’s Plan To Buy?
The proposed project involved 33 battery-electric buses from Alexander Dennis, alongside 13 chargers. McGill’s linked the proposed procurement with an overall investment value of around £16 million.
How Many Companies Applied For ScotZEB3 Funding?
Nine applications were received and all nine met the eligibility requirements. Five applicants ultimately received funding, while four eligible applicants received no grant.
Was McGill’s Successful In Earlier ScotZEB Funding Rounds?
Yes. McGill’s received support under ScotZEB1 and was also involved in the successful Zenobē consortium during ScotZEB2. Transport Scotland records an offered ScotZEB1 award of approximately £9.09 million to McGill’s for 41 buses.
Has McGill’s Won Its Legal Challenge?
No. The Tribunal has registered the appeal and procedural steps are continuing, but there is currently no final judgment establishing that the Scottish Ministers acted unlawfully. (
Are The Existing ScotZEB3 Grants Still In Place?
There is no published Tribunal judgment currently overturning the ScotZEB3 awards. The funding programme continues to list Ember, Rock Road, Lothian, First Bus and Stagecoach as the five successful applicants.
When Is The Next McGill’s Tribunal Hearing?
The Competition Appeal Tribunal has scheduled a one-day case management conference for 26 October 2026 in Edinburgh. One of the issues due to be considered is whether McGill’s Notice of Appeal was filed within the applicable time requirements.